Bring Visitors Back with WordPress Community Plugins

We all like to think our website content and blog posts are riveting enough to keep visitors coming back for more. If you’re doing your job right, that may be working for you to a certain extent.

However, since websites and blogs are built around niches, there is significant potential to addict people to your website for a topical fix of conversation, connections, information and resources. This is especially true of niches that specifically target Canadians.  A sure way to turn your website into an addiction is by taking it to the community level.

A thriving online community offers exciting benefits:

  • New and repeat visitors to your website/blog
  • A community will allow you to be more engaged with your audience than you ever dreamed you could be.
  • Familiarity increases trust in you and your brand
  • As you get to know your audience you’ll achieve friend status. People like to support their friends through social sharing, referrals, and purchases.
  • There will be countless opportunities to promote your own products and services and/or those of your affiliates. Plus, there will be no rules or moderation to stop you. It’s your party and you can sell if you want to!
  • Statistics show that shoppers need to see a product/ad numerous times before they purchase, which is assured with repeat visits.
  • You can turn a one-time purchase into a lifetime customer.
  • Create a whole new revenue stream with “member only” access to some parts of your community.
  • An active community will provide you with tons of blog post ideas gleaned from discussions.
  • Your community’s participants can build your content for you, which will be organically optimized for search engines by default. If your community is open to indexing by search engines, your keyword count will automatically skyrocket.
  • Items like forum posts and classifieds listings count as updates and more frequent updates will bring search engine adoration.
  • Easily provide customer service and your community members can help each other too.

Building Your Community with WordPress

There is no shortage of plugins available for community building with WordPress, to a point that it can be overwhelming. Your selection should be based on what works best for you and your visitors. However, there are other important considerations that should factor into your final decision, including WordPress version compatibility, resource consumption, available support, recent updates, ratings and current reviews.

I’ve provided a few community plugin suggestions here to get you started. The majority are free and the rest are well worth paying for.

Discussion Forums

Discussion Forums are one of the oldest forms of online communication. A member posts about a topic and others are able to offer information, opinions, images, etc. in the “thread”. Social media has given people an alternative, but it’s important to control your community on your own site if you can.

BB Press – A simple forum plugin specifically designed to fully integrate with WordPress by the same company. There are plugins available that can be installed on top of it for more features. The “plug & play” functionality makes it a perfect option for beginners launching a new forum.

WPMU Dev Forum – One of the easiest forums to implement, installing this plugin is as easy as dropping the code into a page. You’ll then have a Forum tab to click for customization and can place it anywhere with shortcode.

Vanilla Forums – This forum plugin is used by some pretty big names, including HubSpot and Mozilla. It includes a native mobile version for use with any mobile device. You can either pay to have a hosted forum, or install a free plugin to host it yourself. Self-hosting requires somewhat intermediate skills and it doesn’t include support. Vanilla is a great option for those who need to migrate from other forum software.

Simple:Press – A feature-rich forum plugin for advanced users. It is an external forum (in that you must upload it to your server), but otherwise it is fully integrated with WordPress.


Most of us are familiar with chat sites, although they were more popular back in the early days of the Internet. An active chat room can be addictive, so it’s a community option worth considering. Today, there are more chat options available for websites, from video to live visitor support.

iFlyChat – Visitors can select from a list of online users to chat with each other privately or together in chat rooms. The chat window can be embedded or in a pop-up. The usual chat features are included, such as emoticons and new message notification.

WPMU Dev Chat – Professional, live chat sessions for visitor interaction. This plugin features unlimited live chats, customization, logs, social log in, Gravatars, and emoticons.

Paid Access (Membership) Content

Membership sites or locked communities offer a way to sell premium content, downloads and features. You can offer a one-time fee, or recurring monthly or yearly access.

Paid Memberships Pro – Easily set up paid or free membership levels for your content or apps. This plugin facilitates one-time and recurring payments through several payment processors.

WPMU Dev Membership – A powerful, yet easy to use WordPress content manager that allows you to split access to your site. This plugin boasts a drag and drop interface, multi-level access, gradual membership access, free trials, customizable payment gateways, and overall flexibility.

Wishlist Member – This plugin offers a paid membership management system. Turn any WordPress blog into a fully featured membership site. Complete with protected, members-only content, member management, unlimited membership levels, and shopping cart integration.

Classifieds and Auctions

Classifieds and auctions are still popular and can be a treasure trove for those focusing on a specific niche. You can charge for ad placement, but there are so many free options that you’d probably be more successful if yours was also entirely free. You can still charge for extra features, however, like the inclusion of a website link, higher placement, or featured listing status.

WPMU Dev Classifieds – Features include paid or free ads, auto-expiration, basic image editing, e-mail, PayPal integration, and compatibility with WordPress, BuddyPress or Multisite. Payment options include recurring payments, one-time payments, or credits. I love the credits feature included with this plugin, which boasts the option to send credits as gifts.

Another WordPress Classifieds Plugin – Everything that most bloggers need in a Classifieds system is included. Featuring paid or free ads, moderation, blind email system, geographical search capabilities, images & video, social media integration, auto-expiration, AdSense advertising, etc. Premium modules are available for purchase.

Directory and Reviews

Much like classifieds, directory and review websites will be most successful if they’re free with paid premium options. Their primary value is usually measured in website traffic, allowing for indirect monetization.

WPMU Dev Directory – This directory plugin offers a fast setup, color and other customizations, shortcode embed option, profiles, automated billing, payment processing, ratings, and affiliate plugin integration.

Connections Business Directory – A simple directory manager with basic templates (premium templates also available). Localization and geocoding features are included.

Event Calendar

An event calendar usually looks like a regular calendar. Event entries are often linked to a page with more details. Niche events are tough to find with your average search engine, which gives event calendars high bookmark potential. You can also include novelty holidays related to your niche to make it fun, as well as acknowledging cause & charity months.

All-in-one Event Calendar – Enjoy a month, week, day, or agenda view of upcoming and recurring events. This plugin includes color-coded categories, sharing with Google Calendar, Apple iCal, MS Outlook and other iCalendar (.ics) compatible feeds, and Google Maps. It also comes with an upcoming events widget for your blog.

The Events Calendar – This events management system boasts multiple views, 3rd party integration (such as Google Maps), and a selection of premium add-ons.


Everyone likes to feel their opinion is valued and it’s interesting to compare our opinions to others. Polls make your site more interactive and can be used to entice people to visit and vote. You can also use polls to gather valuable information about your visitors, from their purchasing habits to what products they’d like to see you develop.

Yop Poll – This feature-rich polling system offers a variety of options for scheduling, display, selections, voting permissions, results management, public archive access, animations, shortcodes and widget functionality.

Social Polls – This plugin ties social media into its poll features, which results in a tool for bringing traffic to your website via social networks. Features include social log in, results filtering, sharing, themes, and voter following.

Notes of Caution:

  • Always back up your blog before installing a new plugin and/or create a test site.
  • Be aware that a successful community can place a heavy burden on storage and bandwidth. Success may come with a cost, but if you monetize it effectively you should enjoy far more gain than loss. Choosing an “unlimited” hosting solution like GreenGeeks will give you lots of wiggle room to get started and can easily facilitate your growth without interruption when/if the time comes to upgrade.
  • When selecting plugins, I strongly recommend going with those that offer updates and support, even if you have to pay for it. You don’t want to have your community go down when you’ve worked so hard to build it up.
  • If you’re using several community plugins, your most economical option would be to get them from one developer that offers a blanket support plan for all of the plugins. For example, WPMU Dev membership comes with excellent support, guaranteed compatibility, and functionality updates.

Getting Started

The most difficult part of starting a WordPress community is the lack of participation. Having been involved in more than a few community launches, I can tell you that the first year will involve consistent, constant effort on the part of you and your friends or staff. Often the only people posting on a forum will be you and your moderators, for example, but it’s crucial that the community look active to draw in more participants.

Eventually, you’ll find the community is more self-supporting and the demands upon you will decrease. The good news is there’s little competition for truly thriving Canadian communities because most people give up in the early stages. You will not be one of those people!

It’s important to use various methods of enticing people to visit or return to your community. Paying for advertising is the obvious method, but you can (and should) get creative here too.

  • Promote certain forum posts on social media and in your newsletter.
  • Have contests
  • Feature active members
  • Be business-friendly by allowing text links and other controlled promotion.
  • Have special guests
  • Work with other communities in mutually beneficial arrangements, such as banner or newsletter ad trades.
  • If you intend to have a paid membership community, offer free access until things get moving. Make it very clear that this will happen, however, or you’ll have some very angry members on your hands.
  • Allow people with free access to earn paid access or additional features for a designated period of time. For example, have a draw for a one month paid membership from those who have made 10 or more posts in your free area, or special contests for those who share your content on social media, post the most reviews, and so on.
  • Be active in other online communities and include your website link with your signature (if permitted). If there are member profiles available, make sure you include your link there too. Social media groups might also offer opportunities to advertise to your niche, but make sure you read and follow the ad rules for each group before posting.

Creating a community is a rewarding challenge for those who want to tackle it. It’s a demanding, long-term commitment that you may want to approach with baby steps. Try installing one plugin and focus on it until that part of your community is humming along, then add another plugin and do the same.

If you can afford to hire someone as a community manager, I encourage you to do so. A talented community manager will make your success his/her number one priority, while you work away at the rest of your empire.

Have you launched any community features on your WordPress website/blog? Please tell us about it in the comments below.

✔ You may also be interested in reading:
All Canadian Retailers Must Engage Customers Digitally, Survey Says
How to Find Info for Your Online Customer Profile (Avatar/Persona)
Beginning Predictive Personalization for Ecommerce


© – Content on this website may not be used elsewhere without expressed permission. Thank you for respecting the effort that we have put into our original content.

DISCLOSURE: We may receive compensation for links to products on this website. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our content is provided for informational purposes only and does not guarantee results.

COMMENTS ARE MODERATED – Legitimate comments will be published after a short delay. Spam will not be published.

Digital Business & Marketing Manager at Online Business Canada | Website | + posts

Melody McKinnon's formal education is in business management, which she enhanced with more than 60 certifications revolving around business, marketing, health, general sciences and writing. In over 20 years of working online, she has owned or managed both educational and eCommerce websites.

Melody has worked with many businesses & brands in a multitude of capacities. She can often be found on, and, as well as other quality digital publications. Her content has earned reference links from highly-respected websites, magazines and university textbooks.

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I am also not sure about building a community on a website because of social media.


I think it’s harder now to build a community on a website because tehre’s facebook groups and social media. If you can do it it’s worthwhile!

Jeanne Lefebvre

I started searching WordPress for plug ins using some of the keywords in your article and found so many more! It’s tough to know which ones are best though. Thanks for your help.

Blake Marsdon

I’m thinking of building a blog network around a niche. I wonder if I could talk my volunteer bloggers into helping with the community voluntarily? It’s a shared profit model that I have in mind, which would make it beneficial to them too. Got me thinkin!


There’s a lot of things you can do for engagement but I use social media most.


Fabulous ideas! I don’t know when I’d find the time to do it but it sounds promising!


Awesome post! I’ve done a lot of research but I still hesitate before taking on a community. Maybe it’s my gut…… or maybe it’s my lack of guts lol.

Maddie Sarnia ON

Building communities IS a ton of work but with it you build a prime marketplace for your products. When you look at it like that it’s well worth the work.


I hope to be a wordpress guru like you are someday. I think it’s an interesting platform to work with


I hope to have a full community up and running this year about Canadian pets. This post has helped a lot, thanks.

Charles Black

I’ve tried and failed but what I didn’t do is keep at it long enough. You’re right it’s easy to get discouraged. With a little more preparation and dedication I might be successful next time.

Barry (Winnipeg)

I had a successful forum about 8 years ago and it was in the hunting niche. I sold it but I’d love to start another one if I could decide what I want it to be about.


It’s still a little scary but I feel better equipped to try a community. I guess I’ll spend the weekend researching and learning more and then take that leap. 🙂


I didn’t know it was as easy as a plug-in. I’ve looked into the software for forums and so on but they’re so expensive I decided not to pursue the idea. Has anyone beside the author tried these plug-ins? How well do they work?


I have to say I love my niche communities but I’ve been afraid to go there myself. This makes the idea a little more……..bite size. 😉

Blake Fletcher

A very thorough intro to WP communities! Forums and chat have fallen in popularity but I agree they’re still firmly in place if the niche is tight.


Some of these plugins aren’t the best for beginners but most with the best features aren’t. It’s worthwhile to learn more about the cms you’re using so you can take advantage of all it has to offer.


You have a way of generating excitement and making me want to learn more. I love WordPress and I’d like to use it to construct a customer community but everytime I’ve looked into it I’ve been overwhelmed. Your information makes it more manageable and doable. Now, I just have to figure out what to start with like a forum or chat.

Tansi Matthews

WOW! Now THAT’S a complete and useful article! I can’t wait to try some of these WP plug ins when my new blog goes live. Very well done, thanks so much!